Final initial native reviews — November 3, 2026

Previous goal turn classification: progress. All43 final initial-review records have been directly inspected as complete native images: one style sheet,22 duplicate legacy runtime encodings and20 catalogued historical studies. Individual reference/history decisions are registered after the preceding verified wetland release. The initial-review backlog is now0; all5,633 remaining qualification records still require their source-specific work. No source artwork, source approval, renderer or world permission changed.

Exact source and decoder reconciliation

All43 catalogued files match recorded SHA-256 and native dimensions. Every legacy runtime copy is byte-identical to its separately reviewed historical sibling, with the original native master and exact prior source-bound recipe evidence retained. Fresh in-memory comparisons against those22 masters show pixel quantization despite unchanged native dimensions; no recipe replay is falsely claimed as fresh. All43 native PNGs (the reference,20 historical studies and22 source masters) agree byte-for-byte between the independent PNG decoder and Sharp. All43 catalogued images load at native dimensions in the browser, and all22 opaque WebP browser readbacks agree exactly with Sharp. No raw readbacks, new previews or artist copies are saved. See preflight preflight.json and native verification native-validation.json.

The ten first-study originals retain their recorded rejection; preservation does not reinstate them as preferred artwork. Broad glows, detached root/foundation contact and scale/style differences remain visible in several. The ten historical ground/strip studies retain their source links and feedback. Recurring terrain groups, material/state truth, physical grain and full normal-context/lifecycle remain independent gates. Continuous labels and runtime paths grant no live permission. All catalogued original artwork and selected finals remain retained under the storage policy, including these historical catalogued originals.

WOG-A-008281

A wide opaque parchment sheet holds ten complete isometric vignettes in two rows: blue-roofed castle, orange-roofed walled town, thatched hamlet, farm, conifers, deciduous woodland, rocky mountain, palm oasis, ice spires and windmill fields. Fine outlines, warm earth colours and small masonry/leaf/roof detail provide useful style comparisons. The parchment joins every vignette; these are not separate transparent live sprites.

Retain as an exact composition/style reference linked to identical public sheet3225. Do not cut out, repaint or treat the sheet as ten independently approved world assets; its varied physical scales, contacts and states remain examples, not production placement contracts. Native SHA-256 c56ebb1361ac90cc07df258a00855c077fcae22337b728bc462546f6c0e17986.

WOG-A-008282

Olive upland ground contains pale diagonal rock ribs, dense small stone marks and tiny green shrub clumps over a brown-green base. Several similarly shaped rib-and-shrub groups recur across the complete square; fine detail looks granular and encoding is not pixel-exact to the master.

Preserve the native master and exact historical encoded copy. Repeated arrangements, physical grain size, material identity, slope state and full normal-world fidelity/performance/lifecycle remain separate qualification work. No periodic mesh-ground acceptance. Native SHA-256 ae3b2d913e4d36ebae59a3b9129f8fd3ebafc2c11c1326f3a33eec03e418894f. Native master WOG-A-001508 SHA-256 a8d5f0eefbe50054c097e4bab8624fb0f8e670e008edf584fe81deb0c01f3ce1; fresh encoded comparison changes1568838 pixels (maximum channel difference33), with all alpha exact and no resize.

WOG-A-008283

The second upland square has larger pale rocky ribs, dark rough mounds, scattered tiny trees/shrubs and open olive-brown channels. The diagonal rocky belts and clustered mounds produce a conspicuous recurring arrangement even though local edges vary.

Keep native source detail; qualify genuinely nonperiodic landscape composition, coherent rock/shrub scale, slope/contact and draw-size grain. This lossy legacy encoding cannot prove original pixel preservation or current renderer use. Native SHA-256 9f73cf70bbd48ca521a9f3cf0450566231927e1ff09997e21e4cb35586d1bd68. Native master WOG-A-001507 SHA-256 2d93e643ffd5913762254a598217a532a201893d93da25a374dbd8e9a56fdefb; fresh encoded comparison changes1569990 pixels (maximum channel difference50), with all alpha exact and no resize.

WOG-A-008284

Grey-white arctic ground alternates numerous dark rocky snowy mounds with broad blue-grey cracked ice pools. Bright snow ribbons and repeated sloping mountain-like clusters cover the square; the fine surfaces remain visibly illustrated.

Retain the native snow/ice master and historical derivative separately. Define ice versus snowy-ground role, physical mound/crack scale, correct seasonal state and whole-ground nonrepetition; do not infer frozen-water traversal or new terrain rules. Native SHA-256 56e264471628cd5754a288ce81c9718b0385a65d04018bd0731762b2a4ddcfd0. Native master WOG-A-001493 SHA-256 d5f13f5bc0abf06416556b59e21d058189aa17a4b776493f84d84229adb57a6f; fresh encoded comparison changes1566183 pixels (maximum channel difference32), with all alpha exact and no resize.

WOG-A-008285

Ochre desert ground is dominated by many low jagged rock ridges and lighter sandy channels, with recurring diagonal belts of raised stone. It is a rough stony desert surface rather than a clean field of tall windblown dunes.

Use truthful stony-desert role and preserve native facet/stone detail. Replace recurring whole-ground arrangement before mesh acceptance, verify grain/relief/contact scale and actual normal-context fidelity and lifecycle, with no arbitrary blur or lossy substitution. Native SHA-256 8a5430e7f96adb3de2390d5c7aeb87f27520248691346e169b2a8f752d4e0098. Native master WOG-A-001495 SHA-256 a1f0d587d6c7dcd164f583ade34e76dd8a4270d47c52ae832498cf38daf34ca5; fresh encoded comparison changes1570401 pixels (maximum channel difference37), with all alpha exact and no resize.

WOG-A-008286

Dense tiny golden/green rectangular plots, dark hedge-like bands, small shrubs and grey stones form a broad agricultural patchwork. Repeated diagonal groups of plot rectangles make this read as many miniature fields rather than neutral soil grain.

Retain the native agricultural painting and encoded history. Define whether visible field parcels are scenery or actual managed land; qualify plot/hedge scale and nonrepeating whole-ground composition without implying playable parcels, crops or staffed production from painted rows. Native SHA-256 2958db737c0c97984b170377f7c091663261d877d471e891e329cc324fa99fc5. Native master WOG-A-001497 SHA-256 7ca578241d14c8823a92721192d538fb7f2d608fd6473851dece94c38bc3fbed; fresh encoded comparison changes1571584 pixels (maximum channel difference55), with all alpha exact and no resize.

WOG-A-008287

Olive-green grassland contains quiet low-contrast grass/soil brushwork, pale scattered stony flecks and tiny rounded shrub clusters. Similar dark shrub bunches and open patches recur across the square, although the surface is flatter than the upland variants.

Preserve delicate low-contrast native grasses instead of smearing or darkening them. Verify nonperiodic shrub/ground arrangement, physical grass grain, shrub size, ground contact/state and complete normal-view performance/lifecycle. Native SHA-256 f8fd0853f1de732e6a2ea233d11198ed25044a37fe6e01b42d99cbc8ba8b90a5. Native master WOG-A-001501 SHA-256 5f3391f79a94c37c8bd0b78a28fe5754efeb50a83e7a04035efb21f7326d2f36; fresh encoded comparison changes1570548 pixels (maximum channel difference48), with all alpha exact and no resize.

WOG-A-008288

Rolling green hills are represented by many raised rocky shoulders and rounded trees concentrated on their slopes. Pale ridge edges and shadowed tree clusters repeat in diagonal bands across alternating open green valleys.

Keep the native ridge and tree detail. Resolve actual terrain relief versus painted miniature hills, relative tree/rock scale, nonperiodic composition and normal placement/contact before mesh-ground qualification. Native SHA-256 dc1af71f995847979ab345a84451dd176298a65663a40c89445df2264caef66a. Native master WOG-A-001503 SHA-256 7c60110bc1e0df80720df7ad09e477a8a375be8095f897eb68f65616e24d63a1; fresh encoded comparison changes1570804 pixels (maximum channel difference56), with all alpha exact and no resize.

WOG-A-008289

Teal lake water has fine small wavelets, broad alternating light/dark pools and sparse yellow-green underwater-looking flecks. Large pale circular/oval light patches recur in several areas and give the otherwise quiet surface a patterned appearance.

Preserve native subtle water marks. Qualify nonperiodic illumination/wave arrangement, depth/state identity, shoreline continuity, physical ripple scale and full normal-world fidelity/performance/lifecycle; an opaque square supplies no bank-contact or transparency proof. Native SHA-256 2c523cd6dcbd6fa6dc1bc926a7c33b0d95c18c53c4e602125b5ed7aaa1780879. Native master WOG-A-001505 SHA-256 5b8849f8120d41e657ce2c2512b1774ef30cdb700e7b9754a87fee9406b43508; fresh encoded comparison changes1555353 pixels (maximum channel difference26), with all alpha exact and no resize.

WOG-A-008290

Deeper blue-teal ocean water carries fine curved wave marks and several larger diagonal bright ripple streaks over broad dark/light patches. Recurrent diagonal highlights and mottled lighting are visible across the complete opaque square.

Keep original fine wave detail and source colours. Whole-surface nonrepetition, sea-state truth, physical ripple scale, coast/water continuity and normal decoder/performance/lifecycle remain open; no acceptance from its ocean name or legacy runtime path. Native SHA-256 b15bf1ee12eb1b46989d8b57374ca9a14c3a51e42cfa09b64fe14ca44260cd1c. Native master WOG-A-001509 SHA-256 6739834bfaf4184097296b232acdce4a320e01575f635a1c0fbe5e9d9245ecb9; fresh encoded comparison changes1561404 pixels (maximum channel difference21), with all alpha exact and no resize.

WOG-A-008291

Muted olive-grey tundra mixes low rocky hummocks, pale frost/snow traces and small dark blue-grey wet or shadowed pockets. Similar rocky humps repeat along a diagonal rhythm, with very fine marks covering the spaces between.

Preserve native frost, tiny stones and low-contrast colour. Define actual thaw/wetness/vegetation state, hummock/grain size and nonperiodic layout; qualify contact, fidelity and runtime/lifecycle without treating blue shadows as proven traversable water. Native SHA-256 60eb098c1f48451e05326dfd734b50a8c80acd90413e11eccaaa379c7db14e0e. Native master WOG-A-001511 SHA-256 bf1b65cf0d1e8327ff6d4e9353fede81246d798a51497f7674e54cab1274dbf7; fresh encoded comparison changes1569577 pixels (maximum channel difference33), with all alpha exact and no resize.

WOG-A-008292

The second arctic square is paler and quieter, with broader snow/ice flats between narrow dark rocky ridges and fine crack networks. Several long pointed ridge clusters recur across the square and dominate the visible landscape rhythm.

Retain source snow/ice detail and historical bytes. Resolve ridge physical scale, ice versus ground role, true nonperiodic large-form composition and normal-world contact/state/performance/lifecycle before any deployment permission. Native SHA-256 7e0fe6781f833944b021a81182e0f68961c5ab3a2c9286f99ffd63c6166464c9. Native master WOG-A-001494 SHA-256 d4e98908ca23f4a1a1bd25e2d025066f3eaf58570bda32480a557efbe3cc8505; fresh encoded comparison changes1557774 pixels (maximum channel difference29), with all alpha exact and no resize.

WOG-A-008293

Golden sandy valleys wind between broad brown flat-topped cracked shelves, with small pebbles and fine pale erosion lines. Large similar shelf-and-channel forms recur diagonally; this variant reads as dry eroded plateaus rather than the first rocky desert surface.

Keep the original shelf and sand detail. Qualify truthful dry-plateau material/relief, grain scale, nonperiodic large forms and normal ground/foreground contact before any mesh use; historical lossy bytes remain reference only. Native SHA-256 f386c1bc643c62164c7b5b1ecbd58fee05c249b4fa08b563ea888624a893cbf1. Native master WOG-A-001496 SHA-256 707d70a182579d5cf88306a4ab6a980d1846b7413d7b3dd5bb369cc7ef110324; fresh encoded comparison changes1569545 pixels (maximum channel difference33), with all alpha exact and no resize.

WOG-A-008294

Larger irregular green/golden fields have curved parallel furrows, narrow dark hedge or stone boundaries and occasional tiny shrubs. The parcels make a recognizable agricultural landscape, with similarly curving field groups recurring across the square.

Retain native furrow and boundary detail. Separate painted field parcels from actual productive land and staffing; qualify physical parcel/grain scale, nonrepeating layout, contact, state and normal-world fidelity/performance/lifecycle. Native SHA-256 2c9a057ebd29027cac0c1f7cb81bf8c1b23511ed21996a42755e80bc9ae556e2. Native master WOG-A-001498 SHA-256 b3f337f021396ff71d5c5896a3381ec3468e31fb6921b85379fc49c065878dde; fresh encoded comparison changes1570740 pixels (maximum channel difference55), with all alpha exact and no resize.

WOG-A-008295

Golden-olive grassland has several long pale ridges or swales, small stony flecks and dark green shrub groups concentrated along diagonal bands. Subtle fine grass marks fill broad quiet areas, while clustered shrubs recur in a visible rhythm.

Preserve fine native grass strokes and gentle tonal variation. Resolve shrub/grass physical scale, whether pale bands depict relief, actual vegetation state and nonperiodic whole-ground arrangement; do not blur away detail to hide recurrence. Native SHA-256 a7d21aa0decf9fd24c58f0460d0dff80553e20508b2c909bc531bc344962c63d. Native master WOG-A-001502 SHA-256 8eb7946239247f7d54308a9f22c0035f778f3fd710c212bc61d009af146bfa53; fresh encoded comparison changes1569541 pixels (maximum channel difference46), with all alpha exact and no resize.

WOG-A-008296

Rolling olive hills have longer pale rocky ridge shoulders, open green valleys and dense rounded tree clusters. The ridge/tree bands repeat diagonally, with a few isolated tiny trees standing between larger grouped forms.

Keep the native tree silhouettes and rock edges. Qualify relief and tree scale against actual foreground assets, true nonrepetition, contact and draw-size detail with the complete runtime/lifecycle checks still open. Native SHA-256 a1e79c690dddd7b779a19c88e7f8754d01cc7faa26ecd0adf3f141c0bff0bf17. Native master WOG-A-001504 SHA-256 9419e8abc9f9bb3b16b984783b0f2bfac3644d1965dc6c17f0dc922978489d6c; fresh encoded comparison changes1569977 pixels (maximum channel difference37), with all alpha exact and no resize.

WOG-A-008297

Muted green-teal lake water contains a fine dense mesh of short wavelets, broad pale cloudy pools and sparse yellow-green flecks. Several larger bright water patches recur across the complete opaque square.

Preserve native subtle colour and wave marks. Qualify nonperiodic illumination and ripple scale, truthful depth/state and shoreline continuity; the legacy lossy image and file dimensions alone cannot establish lake readiness or live use. Native SHA-256 4bd650114392578cfc64f66744adc37ee9bf1e068d48e28ae281a7c9b3a10e8d. Native master WOG-A-001506 SHA-256 7f149c7afa199a1ccbca30c5df991311ba251211b461311812888360d2965fc7; fresh encoded comparison changes1553645 pixels (maximum channel difference24), with all alpha exact and no resize.

WOG-A-008298

Dark blue-teal ocean water contains several broad luminous diagonal swells and thin white crest marks over fine wavelets. Similar parallel crest groupings recur from upper-left toward lower-right, producing a strong patterned sea surface.

Retain original small wave strokes and crest shape. Resolve sea-state and physical wave scale, large-form nonrepetition and coast/water contact plus normal performance/lifecycle; do not tile this illustration merely because it is a runtime asset. Native SHA-256 c297cc6681a7f1b1090a917a8ca012adc4b7db1406a2e65cdc9a048365470ee5. Native master WOG-A-001510 SHA-256 1bc9e9f99563d672538e657189ecc054065720c86d3a0e3e9216d605db781f5b; fresh encoded comparison changes1560531 pixels (maximum channel difference23), with all alpha exact and no resize.

WOG-A-008299

Muted grey-olive tundra has long low stone ridges, sparse dark wet-looking pools, tiny pale frost traces and a few small dark conifer-like marks. Parallel ridge-and-pool groups recur along a diagonal pattern across the square.

Preserve native low-contrast frost, stone and vegetation detail. Qualify actual wet/frozen state, ridge and tree size, nonperiodic layout, terrain contact and full normal-view fidelity/performance/lifecycle. Native SHA-256 18e01d4f6069fb1bd84d93d2d8a768b777b76922ec4fd5ee220bf2fdfc7b8aa0. Native master WOG-A-001512 SHA-256 e453aa1451acc7883faa6a788227e267fb860085e187d79f15533a001538fbfb; fresh encoded comparison changes1570161 pixels (maximum channel difference45), with all alpha exact and no resize.

WOG-A-008300

Golden-green marsh islands surround numerous small blue-green pools and channels. Tiny sedge/shrub clumps border the wet areas, and similarly curved island/pool groups recur across the image.

Keep original fine marsh plants and water detail. Correct the recurring whole-ground layout through an appropriate retained native alternative, with actual water level, sedge scale, bank continuity and complete normal-world performance/lifecycle still required. Native SHA-256 b0a993c0de618cd63f20bf3baf0191d395b408d45f24fcb6fca96ce97b9099cd. Native master WOG-A-001513 SHA-256 b9260b92e967c1ecf5dee401ec1177d16c80c3e0998f0848adce5d95939b5b21; fresh encoded comparison changes1570750 pixels (maximum channel difference56), with all alpha exact and no resize.

WOG-A-008301

Broader blue-green channels weave between olive-golden grassy islands with tiny vegetation clumps, stony specks and fine ground strokes. Repeating diagonal water-and-island arrangements remain visible across the complete square.

Preserve native brushwork and truthful marsh state. Qualify nonperiodic water continuity, plant/grain scale, bank contact and full normal-context runtime/lifecycle; this historical encoding does not resolve the separate wetland reload discrepancy. Native SHA-256 8ca37cc1c7efee6d85d161f6069f02da5c075b84e2d52ca4511e200fe72f0353. Native master WOG-A-001514 SHA-256 78639b91b516d879aa793d62ec1929e012fe1d253140d87845d06acaf56984dd; fresh encoded comparison changes1570716 pixels (maximum channel difference51), with all alpha exact and no resize.

WOG-A-008302

Dense small leafy tree stands form rounded and elongated woodland patches separated by olive grassy clearings and scattered stones. Similar tree-patch clusters recur diagonally, with fine leaf highlights and thin trunks visible in the original-sized derivative.

Preserve native leaf/trunk detail and source colours. Determine canopy versus ground role, coherent tree height and footprint against actual placed trees, nonperiodic forest layout, contact and complete context/performance/lifecycle before any live admission. Native SHA-256 5a0ae7918a97d9bb478cbc25f9059481e16a844603a70efbcd5014bc3baf058c. Native master WOG-A-001499 SHA-256 d9a0fd7c6de333a898534f36b8b27cd7f31aed0713616b3d681446b857fe494f; fresh encoded comparison changes1571617 pixels (maximum channel difference65), with all alpha exact and no resize.

WOG-A-008303

Larger elongated leafy woodland bands alternate with broad open olive clearings, small scattered saplings and pale rocky flecks. Numerous similar tree belts run diagonally across the square, retaining a strong repeating landscape rhythm.

Keep native leaf clusters, trunks and delicate ground marks. Resolve actual canopy/ground representation and plant scale, remove recurring whole-landscape arrangement in the selected mesh solution, and verify all contact/state/normal-context/performance/lifecycle gates. Native SHA-256 269d554c2bd7e54948802571199c5ba8fca89999f1add5d9a946c4a8df3d8744. Native master WOG-A-001500 SHA-256 845d4633c945db487ea31a9c5f10e290e6eec76eee74e58e3dddab172ad57515; fresh encoded comparison changes1571614 pixels (maximum channel difference67), with all alpha exact and no resize.

WOG-A-008461

A complete abandoned mine scene combines a timber-framed tunnel, minecart on rust-brown rails, broken upper winding structure, rocky mound, dead tree and sparse conifers. Fine wood grain, metal fastenings and stone detail are strong, with a broad warm/grey glow surrounding the finite scene as displayed.

Retain exact catalogued historical artwork and recorded user rejection; do not select it over the preferred original. A fresh live proposal would require independent source comparison, cutout/glow diagnosis, rail/crane scale, rocky-ground contact and actual abandoned-state/context qualification. Native SHA-256 9a332249eba97b5837421d1dc6100bc91d95dd9f9de279871a14eaff4d5eabd7.

WOG-A-008462

A dense pale-stone metropolis rises to a large blue-green dome, with many smaller domes, red tiled roofs, stairs, arches, courtyards, a circular arena and a tall obelisk. Numerous tiny architectural details remain distinct; the city is a complete finite composite with broad surrounding warm haze as displayed.

Preserve this rejected historical study and its original source link. Do not replace the preferred metropolis, infer separate functional buildings or grant live permission. Canonical city scale, style, terrain contact and clean alpha plus lifecycle/context remain source-specific work. Native SHA-256 bcb9f020533484686aab9ad4b8f4655aff381b3d98ddbb985bacae450fcb7a16.

WOG-A-008463

Three separate gnarled oaks have pale yellow-green leaf clusters, deeply twisted trunks, hollows and long exposed roots. The largest rear tree stands above two lower trees; all three appear against a broad green/brown glow without a continuous soil apron.

Keep the rejected historical composition as provenance beside the original oak artwork. Exposed root contact, tree scale, fine leaf silhouette and glow/alpha require independent qualification before any world use; do not erase the recorded user preference. Native SHA-256 1b95d37f468e8840374bdd39970f5f127ff06fd1ff1347be55142464c5f72a4d.

WOG-A-008464

A tall broken stone arch and wall rise between fluted columns over cracked paving and steps. Fallen column drums, scattered blocks, moss and isolated stones make a complete finite ruin with crisp stone chips and broad surrounding pale/warm glow as displayed.

Retain exact rejected-study history and preferred original. Qualification of any future ruin must address stylistic coherence, arch/column scale, soil contact, detached fragments and true-alpha boundary on actual ground, without inventing an interactable entrance. Native SHA-256 cf9ee5f3a758c14f27b1faef183086c6e6865f3b849226428cd6c5eab5f6e5ea.

WOG-A-008465

Three separate snowy timber-and-stone structures show a detached watchtower, large central hall with tower and a small right log store/shed. Blue-grey roof shingles, thick snow bands, wood grain, crates, barrels and stored logs retain fine detail, with pale grey glow around each building.

Preserve this rejected historical building composition. Separate snow/seasonal state, relative building scale, foundation contact, alpha/glow and actual canonical outpost role remain open; the picture alone creates no playable watchtower, storage or housing capacity. Native SHA-256 2ba3285bf111360fedf6dd44c3598f9ad01e17a7149f87eff8ae18e56da708df.

WOG-A-008466

Five autumn trees display bright yellow, orange and red leaf crowns, twisted trunks and small exposed root feet. A tall orange tree anchors the rear and two shorter reddish crowns sit toward the front; a strong warm glow surrounds and joins the group as displayed.

Retain exact historical study bytes and recorded rejection. Preserve the preferred original forest and seasonal truth; tree/root scale, complete silhouettes, alpha/glow, forest contact and normal-context/lifecycle must be qualified independently. Native SHA-256 586fe623d22bf8bbc0cde4fa5364c54425bb1fccd9c565c48eff3e52dce8be9d.

WOG-A-008467

Several bamboo clumps form a loose triangular group with thin segmented green stems and sharply pointed yellow-green leaves. A taller central rear clump stands over shorter foreground stands; broad greenish glow fills gaps around the foliage.

Keep the rejected historic study as reference, preserving the original bamboo artwork and feedback. Qualify stem/leaf scale, ground contact, thin-blade transparency, clump arrangement and true state separately before any source admission. Native SHA-256 593d580615991aac07cca4c630118ce95acaab20446104e81f37f383edd06f7e.

WOG-A-008468

Three large square golden grain clumps surround a small open timber harvest shed, sacks, tied sheaves and a wheeled cart. Dense individual ears and straw detail are prominent, while plant and shed size relationships appear strongly stylized; a broad golden glow surrounds the elements.

Retain the rejected study and preferred original. Plant/building physical scale, crop identity and season, ground contact, alpha and normal context remain open. Painted ripe grain, sheaves and sacks do not establish actual crops, stocks or productive buildings. Native SHA-256 29ca8c11ed139eb9341ded3b8fc5efa708c6560c3105190c91aa9f3e3b4ae929.

WOG-A-008469

A stepped mound of dark grey polygonal basalt columns has pale cracked tops, chipped vertical facets, mossy seams and loose angular pieces around its base. The complete isolated formation has a broad grey/warm glow as displayed and no visible smoke or molten material.

Retain rejected-study history beside the preferred basalt source and current bounded smoke repairs. Do not add smoke from the family name, select this different formation as an original-preserving fix, or infer quarry stocks. Scale, contact and alpha/context remain separate. Native SHA-256 a19333abbe3455994c5c57e255801ed83dd0c407a28db6425de1ad61af3bb0c6.

WOG-A-008470

A compact walled keep has a tall central square tower, slate-blue hipped roofs, smaller corner towers, an open paved courtyard, timber galleries, stair and barred front gate. Masonry courses, roof shingles, crates and barrels are detailed; broad warm glow surrounds the whole fortress.

Keep exact rejected historical artwork and preferred original. Qualify fortification scale, architectural style, foundation/contact and alpha/glow in normal context; the illustration does not create usable gates, garrison capacity or wall mechanics. Native SHA-256 aea2fe0ad177c9b1e0fc2327dfac9dd232cd8d17d6797f7da698bf7e054f97c5.

WOG-A-008471

A broad pale snowy/icy ground study shows many small dark rocky ridges, granular snow strokes and larger irregular blue-grey ice patches. Similar ridge/ice groups recur in a diagonal rhythm across the wide rectangular image.

Preserve the catalogued historical mesh study and original source. A continuous-looking rectangle does not prove nonrepetition or coherent physical snow/ice scale; require material/state/contact, complete context/performance/lifecycle and retained artist detail before any mesh selection. Native SHA-256 9392060c675144d778b31d5138a37b7dc12a7c6376b271b0addd80dbef3becd9.

WOG-A-008472

A wide golden-olive ground study has small irregular green shrub clumps, pale stony flecks, quiet brownish gaps and dense fine grass/soil strokes. It lacks the clearly bounded crop parcels of some field sources and retains a recurring diagonal clump-and-gap rhythm.

Keep this historical attempted field ground and its source/feedback. Define its actual grassy versus cultivated-land role, protect native strokes and qualify nonrepetition, physical grain and ground contacts rather than assume agriculture from its filename. Native SHA-256 f867a245247156474268440551e12df70ef4335b34a006690738ff5a2f9387ea.

WOG-A-008473

Yellow-green grassland is crossed by many pale narrow diagonal bands, tiny rounded shrubs and scattered bright stones. Numerous thin curly grass marks cover the wide image, while larger shrub-and-ridge groups visibly recur.

Retain the historical study and preferred native master. Resolve nonperiodic layout and physical grass/shrub/relief scale; do not blur away fine marks, approve tiled repetition or infer normal-view performance from a flat image. Native SHA-256 f10614565b4ab03e61ffc562db2bf053f309c738fbe919d756200696d18125d3.

WOG-A-008474

A wide teal lake-water study contains dense fine curved wavelets and many small bright white crests. Broad muted pale-green underwater-looking patches and mottled lighting vary across the image without a bank or ground edge.

Keep the exact historical ripple study. Qualify actual lake state, nonperiodic larger forms, physical wave scale, shoreline continuity and full context/runtime/lifecycle; no repeatable-mesh or water-mechanics acceptance follows from its continuity label. Native SHA-256 4d349594825c8a38e89826a1b73c5ea83e09ae8013cc557bfd07780c3b9600ea.

WOG-A-008475

A square olive/dark-brown ground study contains dense short curled plant-like marks and small rounded bumps over shallow winding dark depressions. The raised mottled bands recur across the surface, and obvious open blue water is absent.

Preserve the original historical trial and all feedback. Define truthful wetland/soil/vegetation identity instead of accepting a family name, resolve recurring forms and grain scale, and qualify bank/contact/state and full runtime before any preferred selection. Native SHA-256 4af675809027fb221fc856cfe7812aab6a19a6e1b76d9f2aa9240df38635091e.

WOG-A-008476

The second square wetland trial has stronger light/dark contrast, dense shiny yellow-green curled marks, small dark pits and coarse clumpy ridges. It reads as granular mossy/earthy material with little clearly readable open water and a repeated mottled rhythm.

Retain exact historic bytes without declaring it an improvement over the original or the first trial. Actual wetness/material identity, physical grain and nonrepeating large forms remain open, together with complete contact/context and runtime/lifecycle gates. Native SHA-256 047d2784ae7990700a4557fcb0b9178ec30deb1bbda2af9c88606423bcff01ab.

WOG-A-008477

A long isolated rocky slope strip runs from upper-left to lower-right, with a low exposed cliff lip, many rounded boulders, small gravel and sparse yellow-green plants. It has a distinct finite silhouette and broad warm-grey glow around the apron as displayed.

Preserve this finite slope study and its source history. A bounded cliff strip cannot serve as continuous mesh ground; qualify lip height, stone scale, side/end boundaries, alpha/glow and terrain contact against the actual slope role and normal context. Native SHA-256 45a923c9239fd898424922c56e53980ee58f1c132498bc0378933d9bc069934d.

WOG-A-008478

A square teal lake ripple study has many fine curved wavelets, a few brighter white glints and broad pale-green mottled patches. Its quiet water contains no shoreline, reeds or explicit depth markers.

Keep the exact historical ripple variant and preferred original. Qualify nonperiodic illumination/wave forms, water-state and physical ripple scale with full shoreline/contact and runtime/lifecycle verification; a quiet preview alone proves none of those gates. Native SHA-256 2af766572ccb9a89614d1d21e018e53a23f3438f8f46403fe20952e448e02fa7.

WOG-A-008479

A wide high-contrast olive/brown surface has densely clustered moss-like bumps, pale branching curled marks, dark shallow grooves and scattered small stones. There are no broad clearly blue open channels, and similar dense raised groups recur across the whole rectangle.

Retain historical continuous-wetland trial bytes and feedback. Define actual material and wetness, resolve grain scale and recurring groups, and verify nonrepetition, contact and complete normal-world performance/lifecycle without accepting a continuity claim from its name. Native SHA-256 6fa4ec85bd80f3c4db9b2bb1a9a7451645b4c5844f8857e9530eca7f2466869f.

WOG-A-008480

A square golden-olive upland study has many small bright stones, low pale rocky rib networks, tiny dark shrubs and quieter open strips. Fine stone/grass detail is retained, with comparable ridge-and-shrub forms recurring across the full ground.

Keep the catalogued mountain-ground study and original source. Qualify truthful low-upland versus mountain role, nonperiodic large forms, physical grain and slope/contact scale, and normal-context fidelity/performance/lifecycle; do not repaint or downscale it for storage. Native SHA-256 30f8d56223873ec2b0081e226be8e690a048757873a1c6424eb98bd1d971ed8e.

Registration and recovered wetland provenance

All43 decisions are now registered in the local9,205-file Atlas and9,230-record ledger. These restricted reference/history dispositions preserve originals, preferred artwork, rejected-study history and canonical source gates. Forty-four metadata rows await focused publication. No new artist file, source approval, renderer change or complete game-ready approval is added. See registration registration.json.

The exact generation manifest recovers historical study WOG-A-008479's target as WOG-A-003279, original SHA-256 026c6ca78a67c5f5a1a30fb8faf83fbdc1f5792767e6dbb06b95abaa28c87150, and identifies supporting material reference WOG-A-003578. The generated output hash matches the retained study exactly. The first wetland rejection stays in review history; the later continuous study remains recorded as awaiting user review and is not promoted to preferred artwork. See source recovery recovered-wetland-provenance.json.

Additional wetland observation evidence

Ten further normal-client wetland frames use observation-only base-paint tracing at the existing natural desktop site, retaining original source bytes and public algorithm files. Current span2 and original span1.25 each match their reload in base and final ground for this repeat; four complete PNG witnesses are byte-identical to retained prior witnesses, so no new screenshots or raw readbacks are saved. Cumulative wetland evidence is50 frames:40 original-source and10 prior diagnostic-source frames, including30 private-contract frames. The original32-pixel discrepancy remains unresolved; no root cause, deterministic-reload, nonrepetition, fidelity, performance or lifecycle acceptance is granted. The44 queued present metadata rows comprise43 reference/history findings and one original wetland source observation update. See paint-stage review.

Verified live release

Commit 1d9d6b9d0fb83170ffe978e598567863706379c8 deployed automatically and passed exact live verification:9,205 catalog files,70 selected native HTTP identities,88 desktop/phone Atlas views and four gallery layouts. All44 matching metadata rows are synchronized. The complete initial-review register has no outstanding rows; all5,633 remaining qualification records still require their individual work. Originals,preferred outputs,historical feedback,both hamlets,source permissions and /data saves remain intact. No new game-ready source or game-world appearance is granted. The separately prepared ground-role audit,30-frame full wetland trace and Bridge Town water-colour study are excluded from this release.